The Reserve Bank of Australia's (RBA) ban on surcharges for debit and credit card payments, proposed to take effect on 1 July 2026, will, if accepted, significantly reshape the payment methods used in your store. This reform targets surcharging fees that retailers add to transactions paid for using Visa and Mastercard.

I am building on my article from yesterday, which sparked lively discussions. Let's explore the key issues you should consider.

Firstly, this proposal does not address the cause of why people charge these surcharges; the symptom of the surcharge is not the cause. Nor does it address the fact that SMB businesses pay significantly higher fees than larger organisations, often 350% more. The only point mentioned here that is relevant is the greater transparency in the costs. However, it's become quite transparent now. When I reviewed my EFTPOS and credit charges last time, I got, among other documents, a charge table showing the rates the bank would charge depending on my turnover and average transaction value.

If the proposal is accepted, likely fallouts include reduced cash transactions, increased credit card usage, continuing fee disparities between SMBs and large organisations, and some inflationary pressures.

Exploring the Key Fallouts if the Proposal Proceeds

Why Cash Might Fade Faster

13% of payments were made using cash in 2022, which is down from 70% in 2007, and that number is projected to fall to just 4% by 2030, according to Australian Banking Association.

Cash has long been popular for small, everyday purchases, such as a quick coffee or a newspaper at your local shop. Its appeal lies in the simplicity and lack of fees for both you and the customer. However, with surcharges banned, the cost barrier between cash and cards vanishes for consumers. Why would they dig for coins when tapping a card costs the same? This shift would further diminish the role of money, accelerating a trend already evident in Australia, which is what the Australian government aims to achieve.

Beyond diminishing cash use, we can expect to see a greater use of credit cards, as this ban would also equalise charges, leading to another key shift: many will ask, Why use debit when they can get credit for free?

Debating the Consumer Savings and Business Losses

The RBA estimates that Australian consumers could save nearly $1.2 billion annually if the proposal is implemented, equating to approximately $60 per card-using adult. This figure is debatable. Much of this money will shift elsewhere in the system, rather than disappear. That $1.2 billion represents a substantial loss to Australian businesses, particularly the large issuers of debit and credit cards, who stand to take significant revenue hits if the reforms proceed in their current form without changes.

Fee Hikes

Major banks will seek to recover losses from lowered interchange fees.

Running payment networks for Visa, Mastercard, and EFTPOS is enormously expensive. The cost of infrastructure, security, and global operations costs won't disappear under this plan.

Banks will need to pass these costs on somewhere. They might increase cardholder fees, such as annual charges or interest rates. But hiking merchant fees through administration charges is more likely.

Uncertainties Around Overseas Cards and Surcharging

It's unclear whether the plan will allow surcharges on overseas cards, such as American Express or a Visa issued in Singapore. I suspect that some form of surcharging will still be permitted for international transactions. It creates a pain point, as we will need to distinguish between domestic and foreign cards at checkout, which is long overdue. If this is done, we can adapt our POS systems to automatically detect card types, allowing us to handle surcharges without slowing down service.

Potential Inflationary Effects and Price Adjustments

Many businesses that currently apply surcharges are already considering price increases to compensate for the lost revenue. If you are among them, this approach makes sense to protect your margins, but it will contribute to slight inflationary pressures across the economy. If you are affected here, this will require careful handling to avoid alienating price-sensitive customers.

Turning Challenges into Opportunities with Practical Strategies

It's not all downside, as I stated yesterday, these changes will eliminate surcharge-related disputes, thereby fostering a better shopping experience. The reality is that customers hate surcharges.

With the timeline in 2026, you have time to prepare.

One idea worth considering is offering cash discounts after the ban is lifted. It remains an allowable option and can encourage customers to choose cash, thereby reducing your fee exposure. For example, one of my clients offers a free can of drink if the transaction is over $30 and is paid in cash. It worked well.

You need to consider how to adapt your payment strategy.

Written by:

Bernard Zimmermann is the founding director of POS Solutions, a leading point-of-sale system company with 45 years of industry experience, now retired and seeking new opportunities. He consults with various organisations, from small businesses to large retailers and government institutions. Bernard is passionate about helping companies optimise their operations through innovative POS technology and enabling seamless customer experiences through effective software solutions.

Cash Out Day is tomorrow, 22 April 2025. It is a practical reminder that many Australians value cash as a payment. As digital transactions have surged, the movement to keep some money viable has gained real traction. Last year's Cash Out Day drove a 6.2% spike in ATM withdrawals and up to 14% increases in some shopping centres. Most people felt there was no need to withdraw cash unless they went to a place like a shopping centre where they could spend it.

It showed that many Australians still value access to cash.

Supporting Cash Out Day is not just about being opposed to technology (a Luddite); it's about ensuring that cash as a payment method is necessary for our community now.

The Evolving Role of Cash in Australian Retail

Cash usage in Australia has declined sharply. It now represents 13% of consumer transactions, down from 70% in 2007. This shift has created a crisis for cash as the infrastructure needed to support it becomes less viable, e.g. nearly half of all bank branches have closed since 2011, ATM numbers have dropped by over a quarter since 2016, and Armaguard has been struggling due to the dramatic decline in cash usage across Australia. It has been creating a potential crisis, according to the ACCC, for the estimated "one in four Australians who would face genuine hardship or major inconvenience without access to cash."

Does Cash Acceptance Still Matter for Your Business

Customer

The ACCC stated, "Cash is the preferred payment method for approximately 1.5 million adult Australians, who rely on it for over 80% of their transactions." By accepting cash, you ensure your business is accessible to these customers, too.

Financial Benefits

Often forgotten is that Cash payments offer immediate settlement. They eliminate the settlement periods associated with electronic transactions and avoid the processing fees that come with card payments. These fees average around 1.5% per transaction for SMB retailers. These fees are also unfair as they affect SMB retailers more than large retailers.

Additionally, cash provides operational resilience. Digital payment systems experience outages. I had a customer who lost over $8,500 when his EFTPOS went down for most of the day. Australia does not yet have the infrastructure to support a cashless society.

Regulatory Developments

The Australian Government has stated it recognises the importance of cash, but no one has seen it do much. Their recent proposal to force businesses to remove EFTPOS surcharges is unfair as it stands as they have not answered who is supposed to pay this cost. I doubt the goverment intends to pay it.

Practical Steps to Support Cash Out Day 2025

If you want to support Cash Out Day 2025 actively. Here are practical actions you can take to demonstrate your cash commitment:

Take some money out of an ATM

It is what the organisers want, and it indeed is, as you can see that this statistic has been widely quoted. Simply go and take some money out of an ATM. 

Then tell your friends to do the same.

Display Window Signage

Put a sign on your shopfront stating "Keep Cash" or "Cash Welcome Here." This simple gesture signals that you value cash.

Sign and Share the Petition

The Cash Welcome campaign's petition has gathered over 200,000 signatures advocating for guaranteed cash access and acceptance.

Click here if you want to sign.

Create In-Store Promotions

Consider offering a small discount or bonus item for cash purchases on Cash Out Day. After all, many people will have more cash tomorrow and are looking for where to spend it.

The Future of Cash in Australia: Strategic Balance

While digital payments will continue to grow, I feel, and I hope you do, that cash will remain a vital part of the Australian economy for the foreseeable future.

Written by:

Bernard Zimmermann is the founding director at POS Solutions, a leading point-of-sale system company with 45 years of industry experience. He consults to various organisations, from small businesses to large retailers and government institutions. Bernard is passionate about helping companies optimise their operations through innovative POS technology and enabling seamless customer experiences through effective software solutions.

Last week, the "Cash Out Day" protest highlighted a growing tension in Australia's payment landscape: the rapid decline in cash usage and its implications for businesses and consumers. On April 2nd, Australians were asked to go to an ATM and withdraw some money in a symbolic gesture of support for cash. According to social media images, many did. I was one of them. While the exact total amount withdrawn is unclear, from social media, it appears that many did participate. However, the Australian Banking Association (ABA) stated there was no "material difference" in cash withdrawals across the industry on the day. What does that mean exactly? I would like to see figures.

What Sparked "Cash Out Day"?

This movement stems from several factors:

Shifting Payment Habits: Cash now accounts for about 13% of customer payments in Australia, which is a dramatic fall from 60% in 2010.

Bank Policies: Branch closures have created obstacles for cash-reliant individuals and businesses.

Cost of cash: Many people today prefer cash; in many cases, it's cheaper and more manageable, and there are fewer security issues, too.

Banks: Banks make money on non-cash transactions. By closing branches, they are effectively discouraging cash deposits/withdrawals.

Cashless Aspirations: I think the government would prefer to eliminate cash. The Queensland government stated that it envisions a cashless state by 2030. 

Arguments in Favor of Cash

"Cash Out Day" advocates cite these benefits:

Inclusivity: Cash requires no bank accounts or technology, making it accessible to all.

Budgeting: Physical money offers a tangible sense of spending.

Privacy: Cash transactions leave less of a digital footprint.

Reliability: Cash functions independently of power grids or internet connectivity. It still happens that EFTPOS goes out, so what do shops do when they switch to cash?

The Small Business Perspective

In Australia, it is legal for businesses to refuse to accept cash, provided that they inform consumers of their stance before entering into any “contract” for the supply of goods or services. If you want to reject cash, you must have a sign in a clear position in your shop saying that. Usually, it is placed at the front entrance.

Smaller retailers, especially those involved in markets or events, rely heavily on cash. My observations within my local newsagency network showed that while most owners knew about "Cash Out Day," its impact on their daily trade was minimal.

The Uncertain Future of Cash

The potential bankruptcy of Armaguard, Australia's major cash transportation company, further underscores the precarious position of physical currency. This raises concerns about the logistical and economic challenges of maintaining a cash infrastructure as usage decreases. 

The Role of POS Systems

A robust POS (Point of Sale) system becomes crucial for businesses in this evolving landscape. The right software seamlessly manages cash and digital payments, providing flexibility and detailed reporting while ensuring smooth, secure operations. A great POS system helps you manage it all!

The Bottom Line

"Cash Out Day" serves as a potent reminder that amidst the move towards a cashless society, the value proposition of cash persists. This debate centres on choice, accessibility, and the practical needs of businesses and consumers in an increasingly digital Australia.